Click any moment to jump to that point in the video
This segment clarifies the relationship between placebo effects and general belief effects. It explains that traditional placebo effects are comprised of social context, mindsets/beliefs, and natural physiological processes, and that beliefs, shaped by social context, trigger these physiological responses.
This segment explains that our traditional understanding of the placebo effect, based on randomized controlled trials, is oversimplified. It clarifies that while good for testing specific drug efficacy, it fails to capture the drug's total impact, which includes the powerful placebo component.
This clip highlights how positive health outcomes, even related to diet, can stem not just from food constituents but from community, ideas, and the belief that something is the right approach. It emphasizes the often-underestimated power of mindset and social context in health.
Dr. Alia Crum defines mindsets as core beliefs or assumptions that orient our expectations, explanations, and goals. She provides examples of how mindsets about stress, intelligence, food, and medicine profoundly shape our thinking and actions, simplifying complex realities.
Andrew Huberman poses a thought-provoking question about the fervent debates surrounding different diets, suggesting that mindset effects might play a significant role in why people feel so strongly and report benefits from their chosen nutritional programs, regardless of the objective science.
This clip asserts that the effectiveness of a diet is a combined product of the food itself, what you think about it, and what others in your culture think. It emphasizes that social contexts inform mindsets, which then interact with physiology to produce important health outcomes, urging against a dualistic view.
This clip introduces the "nocebo effect," the "placebo's ugly stepsister," where negative beliefs lead to negative consequences. It highlights how being told about certain side effects makes people far more likely to experience them, demonstrating the power of negative expectation.
This clip explains that consciously believing in the effectiveness of your exercise—that it's lowering blood pressure, maintaining weight, etc.—can actually enhance its physiological impact. It suggests that a positive mindset can amplify the benefits you receive from physical activity.
This segment criticizes the current public health approach to exercise motivation, which simply tells people what they "need to get." It argues that these guidelines are not motivational and can even create a negative mindset, making people worse off. Instead, it advocates for helping people reap the benefits of the exercise they're *already* doing.
This concise clip offers a powerful takeaway: it's crucial to pay attention not just to what you're doing, but also to your mindset about it. The speaker emphasizes that "a sense of enoughness" in exercise, rather than constantly feeling like you're not doing enough, truly matters for well-being.
This clip discusses how sleep trackers, while useful, can inadvertently trigger negative mindset effects. If a device gives a poor "sleep score," it might lead individuals to *expect* poor performance or memory issues, potentially making them feel worse, even if their actual sleep quality wasn't as bad. The host prefers subjective assessment for this reason.
This clip explains the foundational research into stress mindsets, how the concept was measured, and the initial correlational findings, showing that viewing stress as enhancing leads to better health and performance.
This clip clarifies a common misconception about the 'stress enhancing mindset,' explaining that it's not about seeking out stress or believing stressors are good, but rather about recognizing that the *experience* of adversity can lead to positive growth and outcomes.
This clip explores the dangers of maladaptive responses to stress, explaining how 'stressing about the stress' or 'checking out' from it can lead to negative mental health outcomes like depression, anhedonia, and substance abuse, because it disconnects individuals from what they truly care about.
This clip delves into the origins of our mindsets, identifying four key sources: upbringing, culture/media (including social media), influential others, and conscious choice. It highlights research showing how online influencers and even movies contribute to unhealthy food mindsets by portraying unhealthy options as desirable.
This clip reveals how the language used to describe foods, particularly by influencers, shapes our mindsets about nutrition. It highlights that unhealthy foods are often portrayed with language of excitement and indulgence, while healthy foods are associated with deprivation and blandness, impacting our perceptions and choices.
Dr. Crum explains how cultural and social forces, including advertising, contribute to the mindset that healthy foods are less desirable. She suggests that media producers and content creators should be more mindful in showcasing healthy and delicious foods in appealing ways.
Dr. Crum shares her personal parenting philosophy, advocating for 'lightening up' on forcing specific behaviors and instead focusing on helping children adopt adaptive mindsets. She illustrates this with the common dilemma of linking dessert to dinner, explaining how it can inadvertently reinforce negative perceptions of healthy food.
Dr. Crum shares groundbreaking research on how reframing mindsets about symptoms in children undergoing food allergy treatment led to better outcomes. This highlights the potential of integrating mindset work with active medical interventions to enhance their effectiveness, moving beyond the placebo vs. drug debate.
This clip reveals unique findings from a study on Navy SEAL recruits, showing that they, unlike the general population, inherently possess an 'enhancing stress mindset.' This mindset was predictive of their success in rigorous training, performance, and peer ratings.
Dr. Crum introduces the concept of 'meta-mindset' and outlines a three-step process for consciously changing one's mindsets: awareness, evaluating helpfulness, and actively seeking useful mindsets. She emphasizes that the question is not whether a mindset is 'right or wrong,' but 'helpful or harmful,' providing an actionable framework for personal development.
Dr. Alia Crum explains the counterintuitive finding from her milkshake study: believing you're eating indulgently can lead to a more adaptive physiological response (e.g., better ghrelin suppression) than believing you're eating 'sensibly' or healthily. This challenges common assumptions about diet mindsets.
This segment explains how a person's stress mindset fundamentally changes their motivation. A debilitating mindset leads to 'freaking out' or 'checking out,' while an enhancing mindset shifts focus to leveraging stress for learning, growth, and better outcomes, even impacting physiology.
Dr. Alia Crum details her famous milkshake study, revealing how participants' beliefs about what they were consuming dramatically altered their physiological ghrelin response, even when the actual food content was identical. This demonstrates the profound mind-body connection in metabolism.
Dr. Huberman and the guest discuss the physiological mechanisms by which a stress-enhancing mindset can lead to positive outcomes. They explore how stress can transiently increase anabolic hormones like DHEA and testosterone, linking adrenaline (derived from dopamine) to these growth-promoting processes, and highlighting the surprising impact of mindset on subconscious bodily functions.
This powerful segment details the results of the groundbreaking hotel workers study. Housekeepers, unaware their work was exercise, were told it was. Without changing their physical activity, they experienced significant health benefits like weight loss and decreased blood pressure, demonstrating how mindset alone can impact physiological outcomes.
This clip offers a powerful conceptualization of mindsets as a 'portal' between conscious and subconscious processes. It explains how mindsets act as default settings, programmed by upbringing and media, influencing physiological responses, and how conscious awareness can be used to reprogram them for better outcomes.
This segment challenges the common perception that stress is inherently bad. It explains that scientific literature reveals stress as a paradox: while it can be damaging, the body's response is also designed to enhance our ability to cope, leading to increased focus, attention, and even post-traumatic growth. The key takeaway is questioning how our *mindset* about stress shapes our physiological and psychological response.
This segment details an experimental study conducted with UBS employees during the 2008 financial crisis. It explains how multimedia films were used to shift mindsets about stress and the surprising positive outcomes on employee health and performance.
This clip discusses a fascinating study where people's *perception* of their exercise relative to others (not their actual activity level) significantly predicted death rates over 21 years. Those who felt they were getting less activity had a 71% higher risk of death, highlighting the profound impact of mindset on long-term health outcomes.
Drawing from the milkshake study, the speaker shares a personal revelation: constantly trying to restrain eating with a "low calorie, low carb" mindset can be counterproductive, potentially making the body crave more. The key, he suggests, is to eat healthy foods with a mindset of indulgence, satisfaction, and enjoyment.
Dr. Crum shares her personal philosophy of 'research is me search,' explaining how her academic pursuits are deeply rooted in her own life experiences as an athlete and in dealing with stress. She emphasizes that her guiding light is the profound impact of mindsets and the vast, untapped potential of the human brain, particularly in areas like the placebo effect, inspiring listeners to explore their own mental power.
This clip offers a profound redefinition of stress, explaining it as a neutral response to adversity in areas we care about. It shifts the perspective from 'coping' to 'leveraging' stress, emphasizing that stress is inherently linked to our values and passions, and should be utilized rather than avoided.
This clip outlines a practical, three-step approach to adopting a stress-enhancing mindset: acknowledge you're stressed, welcome it (as it signifies something you care about), and utilize the stress response to achieve your goals. Dr. Huberman adds that stress can be seen as a 'superpower' when leveraged correctly.