🎯 All Moments (29)
Click any moment to jump to that point in the video
Funny, Wise, and True: The Hardest Element to Achieve in Comedy
Asked which of 'funny, wise, and true' is hardest to achieve in comedy, Judd Apatow states 'funny' is the hardest because it's a gut instinct with no formula. He emphasizes the need to suppress the ego and silence the inner critic to allow creativity to bubble up, describing joke creation as 'jumping off a mountain, not knowing if there's a parachute.'
Overcoming Performance Anxiety by 'Killing Your Babies'
The speaker shares advice on how to deal with performance anxiety, suggesting that comedians should test new material ('kill as many babies as possible') in smaller settings rather than risking a huge show. This allows for failure and learning in a low-stakes environment.
Why Audiences Lose Trust: The Real Reason Jokes Bomb
Judd Apatow explains that a joke bombing isn't always because the joke is bad, but because the audience perceives the performer's nervousness and loses faith. This dynamic also applies to movies, where one bad joke can ruin the next few minutes of material.
How Social Media Killed Niche: Everyone Must Like Everything
Judd Apatow discusses how the internet and social media have eroded niche cultures by making everyone feel pressured to like everything, unlike the 'old days' when obscure bands could be passionately loved by a small group. He highlights how the 'currency of size' and global judgment now impact subcultures, forcing unwanted content into people's feeds.
Judd Apatow: My Parents' Divorce Was 'Enough Damage' to Become a Comedian
Judd Apatow reflects on his early days in standup, humorously comparing his parents' divorce to Richard Pryor's more extreme upbringing, and concluding that his own trauma, though seemingly less dramatic, provided 'just enough damage' to fuel his comedic career.
10 Years to Know if a Movie is Good: The Long Game of Filmmaking
Judd Apatow explains that it can take a decade to truly know if a movie is successful, contrasting this with the immediate feedback of stand-up comedy. He discusses how critical and financial judgments often don't align with long-term audience appreciation, citing examples like 'Walk Hard,' 'Heavyweights,' and 'This is 40' which gained esteem years after their initial release.
Rewarded for Your Worst Qualities: The Paradox of Hyper-Independence
Judd shares how his early trauma led to an obsessive, hyper-independent drive to succeed in comedy, stemming from a feeling of needing to take care of himself. The conversation then explores how traits like hyper-independence, while leading to professional success, can become limiting in personal relationships and overall life balance, highlighting the irony of being 'rewarded for your worst qualities.'
The DVD Money Gap: How Streaming Changed Comedy Film Economics
Judd Apatow explains how the shift from DVDs to streaming eliminated a crucial revenue stream for comedies, making them less profitable for studios. This led to studios prioritizing big-budget blockbusters or cheap horror films that travel well internationally, creating a 'doom loop' where audiences lose the habit of going to comedy movies, writers stop writing them, and new comedy stars aren't developed.
The Future of Comedy: Independent Films & Genre Blending
Judd Apatow discusses how other genres (action, drama) have increasingly incorporated comedy, and how streaming platforms now host many comedy shows, drawing talent away from traditional film. He suggests that the future of groundbreaking comedy lies in independent filmmakers creating low-budget, innovative projects, much like 'Clerks' or 'South Park' did, bypassing the need for big studio money.
The Power of Honest Feedback: Trusting Your Collaborators
Judd Apatow shares a humorous anecdote about his level of fame, then discusses the challenge of maintaining critical feedback when you reach a high level of success. He emphasizes the importance of having trusted collaborators, like his team at Universal, who are not afraid to give honest notes and challenge his intuition, preventing him from releasing untested work.
'Melt Down on the Set': Recognizing Trauma's Impact on Work Stress
Judd recounts his tendency to 'rant and rave' during creative conflicts, driven by a deep fear of someone 'ruining' his work. His wife's phrase, 'Melt down on the set,' helped him realize he was projecting primal abandonment and parental issues onto executive relationships. He learned to separate these deep-seated emotions from work debates, especially before being present with his kids.
The Indispensable Role of Mentors: How Garry Shandling Was Judd Apatow's 'Second Brain'
Judd Apatow reflects on the profound influence of his mentor, Garry Shandling, who provided crucial opportunities, guidance, and confidence throughout his early career. He highlights how Shandling's belief in his work gave him the courage to pursue projects and how a mentor can serve as a vital 'second brain' for creative validation and support.
Brace for Impact: The Value of Painful Feedback in Creative Work
The speaker emphasizes the essential, albeit painful, nature of honest feedback in creative fields. Using examples like script table reads and movie focus groups, he explains how creating a safe space for truth, even if it hurts, is crucial for identifying common criticisms and improving communication in your work.
Beyond Talent: Why Being a 'Good Hang' is Crucial for Creative Collaboration
The speakers discuss how soft skills, specifically being pleasant to work with ('a good hang'), are as critical as talent in creative industries. They explain that producers consider long-term relationships when greenlighting projects, and how a 'room killer' (someone with a negative vibe) can disrupt an entire team, emphasizing the importance of positive social dynamics.
The Apprenticeship Advantage: Work for Free to Become Indispensable
The speakers offer a powerful piece of advice for breaking into any industry: offer your skills for free, over-deliver, and make yourself indispensable. They share personal stories of how this 'apprenticeship' model, even with initial financial sacrifices, led to long-term deals and successful careers by making collaborators realize they couldn't live without their contribution.
The Hidden Mental Stress of Creative Collaboration: Camaraderie Speed Dating
Judd Apatow discusses the 'heartbreak of show business,' where creative groups constantly form and dissolve after projects like movies or TV shows end. This constant cycle of forming deep connections and then separating leads to a unique mental stress, likened to 'camaraderie speed dating,' especially for someone who initially sought connection through comedy due to feeling isolated as a child.
Discomfort and Pain: The Real Catalyst for Comedians and Musicians
Judd Apatow discusses how discomfort and pain serve as a powerful creative catalyst for both comedians and musicians, leading some to humor and others to emotionally resonant art. He questions if significant trauma is a prerequisite for a comedian to be truly funny.
The Unforgiving Nature of Comedy: No Compounding Success
Judd Apatow explains the unique and unforgiving nature of a career in comedy, contrasting it sharply with music. Unlike musicians who build a compounding body of work and can play hits for a lifetime, every comedy project is an experiment where 'one working helps the next one ever.' Comedians are 'only as good as their current performance' and face audience expectations for constant new material, leading to a debate about the value of doing specials versus developing a lifelong set.
The Physics of Comedy: Uncertainty vs. Familiarity in Audience Consumption
The hosts discuss the fundamental difference in how audiences consume comedy and music: comedy relies on the 'uncertainty about what's going to come,' while music is often preferred for its familiarity. This 'physics' of comedy means a comedian's 'well' of material can dry up after one viewing, necessitating constant new content, unlike music which thrives on repetition.
'Practicing in Public': Bombing as Essential R&D in Stand-Up
Judd Apatow and the host discuss the unique challenge of stand-up comedy: it's the only profession where you must 'learn how to do it in front of people,' with 'no practicing in private.' They explain how bombing on stage is not failure but 'R&D,' an essential part of discovering new material. Comedians must bravely experiment, even if it means 'killing your set' to find new jokes.
The Bulletproof Comedian: Bill Burr and Stewart Lee's Audience Dynamics
The conversation shifts to comedians who are 'bulletproof' to audience reactions. Bill Burr is mentioned for his consistent energy and focus. Stewart Lee is highlighted for his unique approach of making the audience an adversary, identifying 'in-groups' and 'out-groups' to manipulate their desire for acceptance and engagement, effectively turning the 'I need to please you' dynamic into 'you need to please me.'
Standup's High-Wire Act: Why It's Different from Writing a Song
The speaker highlights the fundamental difference in the creative process of standup comedy compared to other art forms like songwriting. Unlike writing a song, where practice can be done privately, standup requires public scrutiny for development. This 'high-wire act' nature makes the process inherently more high-risk and socially judged, transforming the accumulation of skill into a publicly scrutinized spectacle.
Keeping Your Ego in Check When Friends Outpace Your Career
Judd Apatow recounts the challenge of keeping his ego in check when friends like Adam Sandler, David Spade, Chris Rock, and Jim Carrey became massively successful, often outpacing his own career. He shares the experience of performing before Adam Sandler at Carnegie Hall and realizing Sandler's laughs were 'twice as big,' leading to self-doubt and depression about his own path and unique comedic voice.
How Pain Fuels Creativity: Hypervigilance and Observation
Building on the idea of trauma as a catalyst, Judd explains the mechanism: pain makes individuals more sensitive and hypervigilant, leading to a unique way of observing the world. This intense focus, born from feeling unsafe and dissatisfied, becomes the engine for creative obsession and breakthrough in art and comedy.
Embrace Imperfection: The Federer Mindset in Creative Work
Judd Apatow discusses the importance of accepting imperfection and taking 'swings' in creative fields, drawing parallels to Roger Federer's loss rate and Walt Disney's creative process. He emphasizes separating the creative flow from judgment and the fear of public failure, encouraging resilience.
Why Intent Matters: The Jimmy Carr Effect in Edgy Comedy
Judd Apatow explains that a comedian's 'good heart' allows them to tackle edgy and dark jokes because the audience senses their underlying goodness. He uses Jimmy Carr as an example and discusses how accusations of 'jokes going too far' often stem from perceived negative intentions, likened to an 'iceberg' of hidden biases. Comedy can also serve as a way to 'pop the pressure' and console the audience.
Jimmy Carr & Douglas Murray: Joking About Sensitive Topics
The hosts discuss Jimmy Carr's perspective that calling a topic 'too sensitive to joke about' is like saying a 'disease is too serious to treat,' framing comedy as a salve. They also reference Douglas Murray's view that true equality means putting up with the same 'shit' as everyone else, rather than being coddled. They differentiate between inclusive, heart-felt comedy and mean-spirited, sloppy jokes.
The Death of Quoted Movies: Why Modern Comedies Don't Shape Culture
The host and Judd Apatow discuss how iconic comedy movies like '40-Year-Old Virgin' and 'Anchorman' used to create cultural taglines, but this phenomenon has disappeared since 2015. They ponder if streaming, lack of box office, niche audiences, and decentralized communication prevent collective consumption and cultural impact.
The Power of No: Why Honest Feedback is the Ultimate Green Flag in Hiring
Judd Apatow shares a powerful story about hiring a director who, during his job interview, gave brutally honest negative feedback on a new show section. This unexpected honesty, prioritizing the product over appeasement, was the defining factor in Apatow's decision to hire him, highlighting the value of genuine critical input.