🎯 All Moments (44)
Click any moment to jump to that point in the video
IVG and Artificial Wombs: Sci-Fi Solutions to Birth Rates?
Stephen Shaw explores advanced reproductive technologies like In Vitro Gametogenesis (IVG) and artificial wombs, which could theoretically allow reproduction from any body cell. However, he expresses skepticism that these sci-fi solutions will impact birth rates, as data suggests pair bonding is a more powerful factor.
Should 21-Year-Old Women Freeze Their Eggs?
Stephen Shaw discusses his evolving, controversial idea of encouraging 21-year-old women to freeze their eggs as a 'positive social norm' to address declining birth rates, acknowledging its cost, difficulty, and potential unintended consequence of encouraging people to wait longer.
Macro vs. Personal: Understanding Population Decline Impacts
Chris introduces the two main ways to think about population decline: the personal impact on individuals who reach old age without family, and the macro impact on the human race, economics, politics, and culture. Stephen agrees, noting that often only the macro perspective is considered.
The Obsession: Why Stephen Shaw is Dedicated to the Birth Rate Problem
Chris Williamson commends Stephen Shaw for his unwavering obsession with the birth rate crisis, acknowledging Stephen's dedication to raising awareness and the significant impact their conversations have had on public discourse.
Supporting Young Parents: Addressing Career & Financial Vulnerability
Stephen Shaw argues that public policy should focus resources on providing support for young parents in their 20s, specifically addressing the career and financial vulnerabilities faced by young women to give them better assurance and security.
UN Projections & Institutional Denial of Birth Rate Collapse
Stephen Shaw criticizes international organizations like the UN for their population projections, which unrealistically assume birth rates will rebound to 2.0. He highlights this as a form of institutional denial, preventing a realistic assessment of the impending population collapse.
Why Careers Are Prioritized Over Relationships in an Anxious World
Stephen Shaw explains that people prioritize careers over relationships because careers offer more agency and feel safer in a world of increasing anxiety and uncertainty. He also addresses the potential misinterpretation that discussions about fertility are 'men telling women not to embrace their freedom.'
The Global Birth Rate Decline: A 9-Year Obsession & The Answer
Stephen Shaw explains that the reason for global birth rate decline has kept him awake for 9 years, and he now feels he knows the answer and has a responsibility to share it. He highlights the severity of the issue, stating no nation has recovered from long-term low birth rates.
Reproductive Synchrony: An Evolutionary Trait Behind Birth Rate Decline
Stephen Shaw introduces the concepts of the 'fatality curve' and 'reproductive synchrony' as the underlying process for birth rate changes. He explains that this phenomenon is not unique to humans, with similar Gaussian curves observed in other pair-bonding species like prairie voles, wolves, and seahorses, suggesting it might be an evolutionary trait that favors societies or species that 'get it right early on'.
How Financial Crises Delay First-Time Parenthood (Not Later Births)
Stephen Shaw explains that sudden shifts in the average age of parenthood are clearly linked to moments of financial crisis. He highlights that while parents who already have children continue their progression, there's a significant delay in first-time births. Using Japan's 1974 oil shock as an example, he illustrates how widespread economic uncertainty caused non-parents across all prefectures to decide 'not yet' for starting a family.
Why the Term 'Child-Free by Choice' is Problematic
Chris expresses his dislike for the term 'child-free by choice,' arguing that the word 'free' implies liberation from a burden, which was ideologically attached to 'child' by certain feminist movements. He highlights that we don't use 'pet-free' or 'vacation-free' for things we simply don't have.
Population Decline: A Collapsing Spiral, Not a Glide
Chris challenges the idea that population decline will be a gentle 'glide down' to an optimal number. He explains that it's a 'collapsing spiral of ever decreasing births,' with birth rates halving in decades, citing South Korea (18 years) and the UK (55 years) as examples.
The Societal Half-Life: A New Metric for Birth Rate Decline
Stephen introduces the concept of 'Societal Half-Life' (SHL) as a more meaningful metric than total headcount for understanding population decline. He explains that South Korea's birth rate of 0.75 results in an SHL of 20 years, meaning births will halve every two decades. This metric highlights the rapid and impactful decline for governments planning infrastructure and tax bases.
Why Adoption Cannot Solve Declining Birth Rates
Stephen explains that adoption is not a viable solution to declining birth rates. In the US, there are 30 families for every adoptable infant, and it's rare for people to give up infants. Regulations often delay formal adoption until children are older (e.g., 8 years old for reconciliation), and international adoption has plummeted by over 80% as many countries, now facing their own birth rate crises, no longer export children.
The Hard Reality of Adoption and IVF
Stephen Shaw debunks the myth that adoption and IVF are easy solutions to having children later in life, highlighting the emotional and financial toll of IVF and the scarcity of available children for adoption, especially for black children from difficult backgrounds.
The Pain of Being Right But Early: Copernicus and Galileo
Stephen Shaw uses the historical examples of Copernicus and Galileo to illustrate the 'Cassandra complex' – the pain of foreseeing a truth but being rejected or punished for it, and how this societal resistance can inflict future suffering.
Controversial Solution: Focus All Incentives on Young Parents
Stephen Shaw proposes a controversial, data-driven solution to declining birth rates: shift all societal incentives and support towards young people (under 30) to encourage earlier parenting, even if it means taking incentives away from older prospective parents. He suggests reinventing careers to support young families.
The 'Daterra' App: Your Probability of Having a Child
Stephen Shaw reveals his idea for a new app, 'Daterra.com,' which would use demographic data to tell users their probability of having a child at a certain age in their specific location. The goal is to inform people about fertility realities and shift perspectives, though the app name choice leads to a humorous tangent.
Rethinking Education: Lifelong Learning and Earlier Workforce Entry
Stephen proposes a radical shift in the education model: taking a year out of high school and college, with people entering the workforce by age 21 to get established younger. He advocates for lifelong learning, where individuals can return to college later, even after becoming parents, which could also benefit universities facing declining student numbers.
The 'Easy Fix' for Birth Rates: Reinventing Our 20s
Stephen Shaw offers a hopeful perspective on the birth rate crisis, stating that the problem isn't a lack of desire for children but 'unplanned childlessness.' He suggests an 'easy fix' involves enabling earlier parenting by reinventing education, careers, and societal structures to support young people in their 20s.
Divorce, Marriage, and the Calculus of Family Planning
Stephen Shaw discusses the complex relationship between the increased acceptance of divorce and women's security in family planning. He acknowledges the historical pain of forced marriages but suggests that a pro-marriage culture with genuine commitment, avoiding breakups, could instill more confidence in young people to form families, weighing the risk of divorce against the desire for children.
The Loss of 'Futurehood' in Japan
Stephen introduces the term 'futurehood' to describe the sense of a nation's future, contrasting the vibrant, youthful energy he experienced in Hanoi, Vietnam, with the palpable absence of it in Japan. He explains that in Japan, the belief in a future is gone, leading mayors to make difficult decisions about cutting essential services.
The Mysterious Bell Curve of Motherhood: Are We Really in Control of Parenthood?
Stephen describes a profound discovery from his research: a 'near perfectly smooth bell curve by age' for mothers across 39 countries and decades. This pattern, which he calls 'We're all the same,' suggests a fundamental, natural force determining parenthood, irrespective of culture, religion, or economic setup. He concludes that 'We might think that we get to decide to become parents, but we don't. something else decides because it's so predictable.'
Why Academics and Governments Avoid the Birth Rate Crisis
Stephen Shaw explains the social and institutional pressures that prevent academics and government officials from openly discussing the uncomfortable truths about declining birth rates. He contrasts their inhibited position with the freedom of those 'outside the tent' to speak plainly.
The Marshmallow Test & Why We Delay Having Kids
Stephen Shaw connects the 'marshmallow test' and hyperbolic discounting to why young people delay having children. He explains that modern society offers more immediate distractions and opportunities (travel, career, entertainment), making it difficult to choose a long-term goal like starting a family over immediate gratification, even if future selves might regret it.
The Economic Disaster of Declining Birth Rates: Retronomics and National Debt
Stephen explains how declining birth rates lead to shrinking GDP, while essential services and pensions are locked in at higher levels, creating an economic burden. He introduces 'retronomics' – constantly retrofitting economies for diminishing returns – and highlights the insurmountable national debts, where a shrinking workforce means future generations will bear thousands in interest per worker per year.
The Shocking Truth: 50/50 Chance of Motherhood at 30 & Why Society Stays Silent
Stephen reveals a critical statistic from his past work: a woman turning 30 without a child has at most a 50% chance of ever becoming a mother. He criticizes society for educating young people about careers but remaining 'completely silent' on the biological reality of time running out for childbearing. This fact resonated widely, even being repeated by Charlie Kirk.
Immigration is a 'Fool's Game' for Fixing Birth Rate Decline
Stephen argues that relying on immigration to solve birth rate decline is a 'fool's game.' He explains that immigrants eventually retire and need care, perpetuating the cycle of needing more immigrants. This creates a global competition for young, educated migrants, with countries potentially offering incentives like free housing to support their decaying societies.
The Thanksgiving Table Pitch: How to Talk About Birth Rates
Stephen Shaw provides actionable advice and key statistics for how to compellingly discuss declining birth rates and the importance of considering early family planning with friends and family, even offering tips for young men to engage in these conversations.
Demography's Unique Certainty: Why Birth Rate Predictions Are Solid
Stephen Shaw argues that demography offers a level of certainty unmatched by other fields, even climate change. He explains that because future populations of certain age groups are already born, demographic predictions are based on concrete data, making the impending population decline an undeniable truth.
Beyond Money: How Declining Birth Rates Impact Everything in Your Life
Stephen argues that declining birth rates impact 'almost everything in your life, young and old,' especially the young. He explains how social care, pension systems, and healthcare will 'whittle away' without enough workers. He refutes the idea that it's 'just about money' or 'supporting boomers,' emphasizing that it affects everyone, leading to competition for essential services.
The Shocking Truth: Birth Rate Decline is About Childlessness, Not Fewer Kids Per Family
Stephen shares a crucial discovery from his research: the decline in birth rates is not due to mothers having fewer children, but rather fewer women becoming mothers overall. He provides data showing that mothers in the US, UK, and Japan are having roughly the same number of children today as in the 1970s and 80s (e.g., US mothers 2.4 then, 2.6 now). This challenges a common misconception, pointing to childlessness as the primary driver.
Life Design vs. Life History: The Myth of 'Having It All'
Stephen Shaw contrasts 'life design' (the idea that you can design your perfect life and have it all) with 'life history' (the biological and statistical realities of reproduction). He argues that the expectation of having education, travel, career, and family all line up perfectly is a myth, leading to disappointment and the realization that trade-offs are necessary.
The 'Town Dance' Analogy: How Stretched Timelines are Collapsing Fertility
Stephen explains that as the average age of motherhood extends, the bell curve of fertility flattens and collapses at an accelerating rate. He uses the 'town dance' analogy: if a 3-hour dance (early 20s) is stretched to 6 hours (20-40ish), the same energy (population) is distributed, leading to less vitality. This reduced 'vitality' means a lower chance of meeting someone for a lifetime commitment, especially for child-rearing, because people are no longer on the same page regarding timelines and goals.
Why the Population Can Grow While Birth Rates Decline: The Hans Rosling Analogy
Stephen explains the counterintuitive phenomenon of a global population still increasing while birth rates decline. He clarifies that population is primarily determined by births (which predict future births), not just births and deaths. Using an analogy (Hans Rosling's wave), he illustrates how better healthcare and longer lifespans create an aging population, masking the underlying decrease in young people and new births, leading to a 'cognitive issue' for many.
Why Local Grievances Don't Explain Global Birth Rate Decline
Stephen Shaw explains why common local grievances like house prices or work-life balance are insufficient explanations for the global phenomenon of declining birth rates. He introduces the 'local grievance razor,' arguing that widespread trends require widespread causes, not country-specific issues.
The Flawed 'Average Woman': Why TFR Misses the Mark on Birth Rates
Stephen Shaw criticizes the Total Fertility Rate (TFR) for relying on the concept of an 'average woman' who doesn't exist. He introduces his measure, the Total Maternal Rate (TMR), which differentiates between mothers and non-mothers. The TMR shows that while mothers continue to have children at similar rates, the proportion of women *becoming* mothers has sharply declined since 2008-09, leading to a significant increase in 'unplanned childlessness' where 3 out of 10 women in America today will not have children despite wanting them.
The Ratchet Effect: Why Delayed Parenthood Becomes Permanent
Stephen Shaw explains why the average age of parenthood, once shifted later due to financial crises, tends to stay locked in and doesn't revert even during prosperous times. He describes this 'ratchet effect' through societal synchrony, where delaying parenthood becomes a norm and a rational choice for individual financial security. Using the Japanese 'senpai/kohai' employment system as an example, he illustrates how social hierarchies can reinforce the risk aversion associated with having children earlier, making it incredibly difficult to shift the curve back.
The 'Little Sister Syndrome' and the Shifting Dating Market
Stephen Shaw introduces the 'little sister syndrome' as a factor in delayed parenthood. As the dating window shifts later, men have more options with younger women, leading to a 'distraction' that can induce them to delay commitment. This often results in men 'trading down' for younger partners, which, while potentially allowing the younger woman to have children, severely disadvantages older women by pushing them out of the mating pool and increasing their likelihood of involuntary childlessness.
The 'Half-Truths' of Anti-Natalism and the Missing Fertility Education
Stephen Shaw questions the motivations behind anti-natalist movements, highlighting that well-funded organizations from the 60s and 70s, like Paul Erlich's 'Population Connection', still promote 'half-truths' to millions of high school students. He argues that while sex education excels at preventing pregnancy, it critically fails to inform young people about the female fertility window, the limited time frame for having children, and the realistic chances of parenthood at different ages, leading to widespread 'unplanned childlessness'.
Anti-Natalist Progressives: An 'Ideological Seppuku'
Chris argues that anti-natalist progressives are engaged in 'ideological seppuku' because behavioral genetics shows political ideology is partly heritable. If left-leaning people stop having children, the future will be inherited by pro-natalist groups (religious, conservative, Amish) who will pass on their ideologies, effectively defeating the progressive cause.
The 'Worst Chart in Science': Misrepresenting Children's Climate Impact
Stephen dissects a deeply flawed chart, published in The Guardian, that drastically exaggerates the climate impact of having a child. He explains that the 'grapefruit-sized' impact of one child was calculated by lumping together their entire lifetime emissions with those of their assumed two children, their children's children, and so on, for 200 years, misleadingly comparing it to small actions like a single flight.
The Unseen Grief: 80% of Childless Women Didn't Intend To Be
Chris and Stephen discuss the overwhelming statistic that 80% of women who reach menopause without children didn't intend to be childless. They highlight the paradox of online anti-natalist rhetoric when so many women experience 'unplanned childlessness' and grief over families they never had. Stephen shares a poignant story of a 35-year-old woman distraught after a breakup, expressing her sole desire for a family, illustrating the profound emotional impact of this societal trend.
The Tragic Reality of Loneliness in Japan's Decaying Suburbs
Stephen recounts a powerful and moving experience while filming his documentary in a Tokyo suburb. He describes once-burgeoning luxury apartments now 98% occupied by lonely elderly people, with grassed-over playgrounds. The most heartbreaking detail is the local pharmacy and grocer confirming that a 90-year-old woman jumping off a roof due to loneliness 'happens every week.'